Monthly Business Meeting

7:00 PM – 9:25 PM 9 present 14 motions

The Halifax Township Board of Supervisors held its monthly business meeting on February 9, 2009, with all five supervisors present: Chairman Norma Shearer, Linda Ruff, Carol Eppley, Ken Hoover, and Gary Shultz. The nearly two-and-a-half-hour session featured an unusually charged public comment period, with nine residents pressing the board on transparency, communication, and building permit fees, setting the tone for a meeting that produced several split votes and tabled items.

  • Building permit fee dispute headed toward resolution: Solicitor Steve Dzuranin reported that further investigation is needed before he can determine whether the township violated its permit fee structure. The board unanimously approved sending a letter to the Home Builders Association expressing a desire to cooperate and resolve the matter without litigation. Multiple residents voiced concerns, with one noting a single permit application exceeded $13,000.

  • Harman Stove Company financial security released: The board unanimously approved releasing $140,651.50 of the $158,031.50 in financial security held for the Harman Stove Company land development plan, retaining $17,380 for remaining work.

  • Tax collector compensation unchanged (3-2): The board narrowly voted to keep the tax collector's pay at $2 per bill for Real Estate and $0.25 per bill for Per Capita taxes. Ken Hoover and Gary Shultz voted no after Tax Collector Melinda Warfel presented PSATS guidelines showing the current rates fall below allowable levels and below what she received as recently as 2002.

  • Delinquent tax collection transferred from UDITO to JP Harris: After the UDITO Advisory Board discovered that municipalities had been overpaid — requiring repayment to be deducted from the township's February EIT distribution — the board unanimously voted to have JP Harris take over per capita delinquent tax collection.

  • HARA funding request tabled: HARA requested $37,004 for 2009, nearly $8,500 above the $28,500 budgeted. Resident Todd Etzweiler urged the board not to increase funding and suggested HARA sell its "North Park" property. The matter was deferred until Tracy Cox can present a full financial report at the March meeting.

  • ADA curbing declined; street light retained (4-1): The board passed on PennDOT's offer to install ADA-compliant curbing on Green and Boyer streets during N. River Road paving at an estimated cost of $20,000. Separately, the board voted 4-1 to keep a street light at Sycamore and S. River Road after the medical center requested it remain; Linda Ruff cast the lone dissenting vote and asked for a written street light policy.

  • Fire Company contract under review: Todd Etzweiler flagged that the Fire Company's contract to collect fire taxes expired on December 31, 2006, and cited items the Fire Company has not complied with. The board unanimously authorized Solicitor Dzuranin to research the matter.

  • Gypsy moth spraying costs absorbed by township: The board voted unanimously to pay the full cost of gypsy moth spraying rather than invoicing affected residents, a decision applauded by several attendees during the public comment period.

Norma Shearer (Chairman, Supervisor) · Linda Ruff (Supervisor) · Carol Eppley (Supervisor) · Ken Hoover (Supervisor) · Gary Shultz (Supervisor) · Dale Shoop (Roadmaster) · David Hoover (Secretary/Treasurer) · Tom Wilson (Engineer) · Steve Dzuranin (Solicitor)

Gary Shultz — Asked for everyone's cooperation in community actions and questioned whether the board wishes to conduct business by harassment.
Florence McGuire — Reported that Eileen Snyder collected 559 signatures to establish a library. Asked for HARA financial statements and inquired whether March 10, 2009 was available for the meeting room.
Bob Burrell — Asked to be placed on the March agenda to discuss Fellowship Drive and gave the Solicitor documents for review.
Donna Rode — Stated that the citizens of Halifax Township are angry with the board's actions and that it is a free country with free speech.
Bob Artman — Suggested making investments with funds from the checking account, asked that expense categories be identified on bills to be approved, and requested fixed assets be included on the balance sheet.
Deb Lebo — Expressed interest in township affairs and asked why there wasn't more communication with citizens about decisions being made.
Flo Mallonee — Asked that the public be given the opportunity to voice their opinion before the board makes decisions.
Jerry Kissinger — Expressed frustration that questions are not answered during public comment and that it took too long to receive a response to the letter he wrote to the Supervisors.
Colleen Smith — Asked about the building permit issue, questioned whether Linda Ruff would stay overnight at the PSATS convention at citizen expense, and voiced disapproval of moving the township office.

Secretary/Treasurer's Report

Bill Approval

The paid interim bills and unpaid current bills were presented. Carol Eppley moved to approve the bills as presented, seconded by Linda Ruff; the motion carried with all in favor except Ken Hoover, who was opposed. Ken Hoover asked whether two street signs were the office signs at the Township Office.

budget
4-1 Approve the paid interim bills and unpaid current bills as presented.
Moved by Carol Eppley
Minutes Approval

The January 5 Reorganization Meeting, January 12 Business Meeting, and January 12 Act 537 Planning Meeting minutes were presented. Gary Shultz moved to approve all minutes as presented, seconded by Carol Eppley; the motion carried unanimously.

planningact-537
5-0 Approve the January 5 Reorganization Meeting, January 12 Business Meeting, and January 12 Act 537 Planning Meeting minutes as presented.
Moved by Gary Shultz

Planning Commission

Commissioner Office Key Issuance

Keys to the back office will be issued to Planning Commission members upon request, as members feel they need access. Linda Ruff motioned to approve the key issuance, seconded by Carol Eppley; the motion carried unanimously.

planning
5-0 Approve issuing keys to the back office upon request as members feel they need access.
Moved by Linda Ruff

Engineers Report

Harman Stove Company Land Development Plan – Financial Security Release

Of the $158,031.50 in financial security currently held, K&W Engineers recommended releasing $140,651.50 and retaining $17,380.00. Linda Ruff motioned to approve the recommendation, seconded by Carol Eppley; the motion carried unanimously.

land-developmentcontracts
5-0 Approve the recommendation to release $140,651.50 of the $158,031.50 financial security held for Harman Stove Company Land Development Plan, retaining $17,380.00.
Moved by Linda Ruff $140,651.5
River Ridge Mobile Home Park – Time Extension

A time extension request was presented and recommended for approval by the engineer. Carol Eppley motioned to approve, seconded by Ken Hoover; the motion carried unanimously.

land-developmentproperty
5-0 Approve the time extension request for River Ridge Mobile Home Park.
Moved by Carol Eppley

Solicitors Report

Building Permit Fees – Letter to Home Builders Association

Solicitor Dzuranin explained his research into the Township's building permit fee structure, stating further factual investigation is needed before advising whether the Township violated the fee structure. He suggested sending the Home Builders Association a letter expressing the Board's wish to cooperate and resolve the matter short of litigation. Linda Ruff motioned to approve sending the letter, seconded by Carol Eppley; the motion carried unanimously.

permitslegal
5-0 Approve sending a letter to the Home Builders Association expressing the board's sincere wish to cooperate and resolve the building permit fee matter short of litigation.
Moved by Linda Ruff

Roadmasters Report

ADA Curbing – N River Road Paving

Roadmaster Dale Shoop reported that PennDOT offered the Township the option to install ADA curbing on Green and Boyer streets during the paving of N River Road at a cost of approximately $20,000. The board chose not to have the ADA curbing installed.

roadsinfrastructure
Street Light at Sycamore and S. River Road

A resident requested removal of a street light at Sycamore and S. River Road, but the medical center wished it to remain. Ken Hoover motioned to keep the light in place, seconded by Carol Eppley; the motion carried with all in favor except Linda Ruff. Linda Ruff suggested considering not having individuals pay for street lights and asked that the topic be placed on the March agenda; a written policy will be developed over the next several months.

infrastructureutilities
4-1 Keep the street light at Sycamore and S. River Road in place.
Moved by Ken Hoover

Old Business

HARA Budget Request

HARA requested $37,004 from the Township for 2009, but only $28,500 was budgeted. Gary Shultz suggested increasing the amount on a matching funds basis. Linda Ruff suggested tabling the issue until Tracy Cox can report back at the March meeting.

budgetrecreation
Gypsy Moth Spraying – Resident Invoicing

Norma Shearer recommended the Township pay the entire cost of gypsy moth spraying and not invoice the affected residents. Carol Eppley motioned to approve the recommendation, seconded by Gary Shultz; the motion carried unanimously.

environmentbudget
5-0 Approve the recommendation that the Township pay the entire cost of gypsy moth spraying and not invoice the residents who receive the spraying.
Moved by Carol Eppley
UDITO – Per Capita Delinquent Tax Collection

The UDITO Advisory Board discovered that UDITO overpaid municipalities, which must be repaid; a special distribution will offset most of the overpayment, with the balance deducted from the February EIT check. Norma Shearer recommended that per capita delinquent taxes be collected by JP Harris rather than UDITO. Ken Hoover motioned to have JP Harris collect the per capita delinquent taxes, seconded by Carol Eppley; the motion carried unanimously.

taxesbudget
5-0 Have JP Harris collect the per capita delinquent taxes in place of UDITO.
Moved by Ken Hoover
Fort Halifax Park Use

Salyn Stover of DCNR informed Norma Shearer that the Township is responsible for safety issues for park use, and the property can no longer be farmed. Norma Shearer stated the park is not ready for use because safety issues have not been identified and addressed. David Kieffer will be informed he can no longer farm the property, and Larson Design Group has been selected as the Master Site Plan consultants.

fort-halifaxparks
Act 537 Planning Meeting – Guest Speaker

Norma Shearer suggested inviting Rudi Erb of Twin Valley Conservation Association as a guest speaker at the March 24 Act 537 meeting. Linda Ruff voiced concern over the meeting length, and after discussing pros and cons, the Board decided not to include her as a speaker.

act-537planning
Fire Company Contract

Todd Etzweiler noted the contract to collect fire taxes expired 12/31/06 and cited various items in the contract the Fire Company has not abided by. The subject was tabled for research. Linda Ruff motioned to authorize Solicitor Dzuranin to research the matter, seconded by Carol Eppley; the motion carried unanimously.

contractslegalemergency-services
5-0 Authorize Solicitor Dzuranin to research the Fire Company contract matter.
Moved by Linda Ruff

New Business

PSATS Convention – Lodging

Lodging for Norma Shearer and Linda Ruff was requested for the entire PSATS Convention, as attending early and staying late provides the full benefit. Gary Shultz asked for a cost comparison between staying and commuting. After discussion, the motion to approve lodging was voted upon and carried unanimously.

personnelbudget
5-0 Approve lodging for Norma Shearer and Linda Ruff for the entire PSATS Convention.
Moved by Norma Shearer
UD Human Services Donation

UD Human Services requested a donation. Gary Shultz motioned to donate $250, seconded by Carol Eppley; the motion carried unanimously.

budgetcommunity-events
5-0 Donate $250 to UD Human Services.
Moved by Gary Shultz $250
Tax Collector Compensation

The Tax Collector is currently paid $2 per bill for Real Estate tax and $0.25 per bill for Per Capita tax. Linda Ruff motioned to leave rates unchanged, seconded by Ken Hoover. Melinda Warfel shared PSATS guidelines and her payment history since 2002. The motion was approved with Gary Shultz and Ken Hoover opposed.

taxespersonnel
3-2 Leave the tax collector compensation rates unchanged at $2 per bill for Real Estate tax and $0.25 per bill for Per Capita tax.
Moved by Linda Ruff

Adjournment

Linda Ruff motioned to adjourn at 9:25 PM, seconded by Carol Eppley; the motion carried unanimously.

5-0 Adjourn the meeting.
Moved by Linda Ruff

This page is an automated summary of official township records. For the authoritative version, always refer to the original document.